Key findings

service quality

Implementation and aims

The pilot in the Netherlands can be characterised as a quick screening for low literacy, followed by referral to appropriate training facilities where the education and coaching would take place. In the Netherlands, the focus is on three intervention strategies:

  • Tools – At the heart of the GOAL project in the Netherlands is a Literacy Screener, the Taalmeter. This is an online tool with which organisations can identify quickly and easily those people who may have difficulty reading.
  • Outreach activities – In terms of reaching out to service users with low literacy, gains can be made in the Netherlands. That is why this outreach aspect forms the core of the Dutch GOAL intervention. This outreach involves expanding the number and range of identification sites where people are screened for low basic skills in an accessible setting (organisations in which people enter for a completely different – i.e. non-literacy-related – reason).
  • High-quality guidance services – The evaluation study linked to the GOAL pilot offers leads for improving the guiding process – low literacy screening and referral to a suitable language course in organisations where tackling low literacy is not the main task – and for implementation on a larger scale in the Netherlands.

Strengths and achievements

The major success of the Dutch GOAL pilot is the successful screening of people who potentially have low basic skills in an accessible setting. In the four pilot organisations, use of the Literacy Screener was implemented into regular work processes. This was possible with a devoted person ‘carrying the load’ in each organisation. At their arrival, clients are asked to take the Literacy Screener as standard. Programme staff members found good ways to introduce the Literacy Screener to clients. In general, clients react well to the Literacy Screener and are cooperative. This is confirmed by the outcome of the client satisfaction survey and the follow-up interviews with participants.

The Literacy Screener is conducted by people who have time to do so (in many cases unpaid workers: trainees or volunteers). The tool can be conducted quickly and easily, and the outcome provides information that helps organisations develop their services further. Together, during the GOAL pilot, they conducted 1,525 Literacy Screeners (far more than the intended 400), identifying 465 people with potential low literacy.

Challenges and barriers

The follow-up (i.e. the flow of clients with an unsatisfactory score on the Literacy Screener into language courses) is the major weakness of the Dutch intervention. Especially in the municipality of Emmen and PI Lelystad, this inflow is very low. In all four pilot organisations, various departments/functions are involved in the guidance process. In the municipality of Emmen and PI Lelystad, however, there is no common vision or integrated approach yet. This makes setting up a proper follow-up for clients more difficult.

In this evaluation study, it was found that a considerable number of clients (especially in the municipality of Emmen, but on a smaller scale also in PI Lelystad and PI Achterhoek) were not willing to consider taking a language course. In the first place, clients do not recognise or admit they have language problems (this applies to clients from the municipality of Emmen whose native language is Dutch). On the one hand, a sense of shame has some influence here. On the other hand, some clients really do not recognise the added value or the practical importance of a language course. Speaking a language is only one part of literacy; there is also reading and writing. It seems that because people speak fluently Dutch, they feel that they have no need of improvement in the other aspects of language. In the second place, taking a language course takes time which clients would rather spend on something else.

Additionally, the penitentiary institutions experience specific difficulties that are related to the special nature of the organisations: limited capacity (limited number of language volunteers available), complicated planning (including language courses in the detainees’ schedule and the language volunteers’ schedule) and difficulty of monitoring continuity (detainees are transferred to other departments, sometimes suddenly, or are released from prison).

Baseline and progress across GOAL’s five intervention strategies

The table below provides a brief evaluative summary of the quality of different aspects of the GOAL programme in the Netherlands, comparing quality at the start of the evaluation (baseline) and at the end. In this table, we provide numerical ratings for each of the five intervention areas, and an explanation of that rating for each category. These ratings and explanations are provided for the start of the evaluation and the end, with the aim of briefly summarising key issues and change over time. In addition to provide ratings and commentary for the five core GOAL intervention areas, we also address overall service quality and policy interest/support. The latter is a key factor in determining future programme sustainability.

Table: Summary of the quality of different aspects of the GOAL programme in the Netherlands (pdf, 3 p.) (95 kB)

A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A COUNSELLOR

Iceland
Iceland

"GOAL interview: a client came to discuss a program for validation of employability skills, in which she is going to participate."

"In-house discussions with other counsellors and project managers on an unexpected issue with a student. We tried to solve the issue together. We had to contact another school."

Lithuania
Lithuania

“Presentation for unemployed people about possibilities to get involved into the Goal project and get free of charge orientation and guidance.”

“Orientation and guidance of adult people. 2 clients are consulted: they are unemployed and have plans for learning a new profession in order to find a job.“

Netherlands
Netherlands

“The prison population and educational needs of the detainees are far from homogeneous.”

 “Usually, there are 6 to 8 detainees at a time, each with an individual program. I guide them. The guidance can be focused on basic education, vocational education or specific courses detainees are taking at that time”

Slovenia
Slovenia

"Working with clients gives me energy and brings me joy, because between individual sessions I can see progress, changes, new beliefs, enrolment in education programmes and I can build good relationships with my clients."

 

"The feeling that I do a lot of good for my clients is priceless."

Czech Republic
Czech Republic

“At the start of every session, counsellors try to gather information about the client, his or her position within the family and wider friendship circles, and his or her health. They also explore the client’s feelings, ideas and motivation.”

“Based on the client’s answers, the counsellor selects ways to proceed in order to meet the client’s needs and goals.”

Flanders
Flanders

"All information, agreements made and steps taken during sessions are written down in the registration system"

“Even the names of persons clients have been talking about are registered in order to remember the whole communication line and, more importantly, to avoid them having to say things twice. It creates a sense of trust with our clients.”

TESTIMONIALS

from clients, counsellors and stakeholders

Navigatie

Contact Info